Thursday, July 5, 2012

Why rugged cameras are not as rugged as you'd think




If you've ever read user reviews of rugged or waterproof cameras, you probably wouldn't think they could handle having a glass of water spilled on them, let alone a 33-foot dive in the ocean.


The fact is, however "rugged" a manufacturer says a camera is, whether it can survive such treatment has a lot to do with the user. Maybe too much.


For example, the top-rated Olympus Tough TG-1 iHS is marketed with some of the highest durability claims for a compact camera: waterproof down to 40 feet, shockproof up to a 6.6-foot drop, freezeproof to 14 degrees Fahrenheit, and crushproof up to a weight of 220 pounds. That sounds pretty great and it is, but there's a bunch of fine print that goes with that marketing message.


Buried at the back of the TG-1's operation manual (page 70 of 80 pages) are the specifics for its water and shock resistance. According to the manual its "waterproof feature is warranted* to operate at depths up to 12m (39.8 feet) for up to 1 hour." The asterisk on "warranted" refers to a footnote on how Olympus arrived at that rating:


As determined by Olympus pressure testing equipment in accordance with IEC Standard Publication 529 IPX8. This means that the camera can be used normally underwater at a specified water pressure.

As it says, the IPX8 code ... [Read more]




No comments:

Post a Comment